Nilson Brand Law Attorney group shot

Attorneys Who Give It To You Straight

Photo of the attorneys at Nilson Brand Law.

Hearsay: understanding second-hand evidence

On Behalf of | Apr 12, 2024 | Criminal Defense

The courtroom thrives on the truth and demands a meticulous presentation of evidence. However, during legal proceedings, there is a concept called hearsay or second-hand information which introduces a layer of uncertainty due to credibility issues.

Is hearsay not admissible in court?

Hearsay includes statements made outside of court that parties try and use as evidence.

Hearsay is not always admissible in court. The court prioritizes first-hand accounts made in court because relayed information through multiple individuals may be inaccurate, distorted, and exaggerated. Additionally, the original speaker is not present for cross-examination, making assessing their motives and memory difficult. However, there are legal exceptions.

  • Business records: Documents like medical reports and receipts created within the business for legitimate purposes may be dependable.
  • Dying declarations: Statements from individuals on their deathbed are admissible under certain conditions. The rationale is that people tend to be more truthful when they are about to die.
  • The speaker is not available: If the firsthand witness is sick or away, a judge may consider hearsay evidence if it significantly affects the case.

These specific conditions for admitting hearsay evidence vary by area and state. Even when the exception applies, it depends on the judge if the evidence is unreliable or unfairly prejudicial.

The strength of a witness testimony

Witness testimony can be vital in criminal cases. It allows firsthand accounts from witnesses who may have seen or heard an event and can provide a unique perspective. They are also present for cross-examination that challenges their perception, memory, and potential biases.

However, witness testimony is far from perfect. Issues with accuracy and bias can arise, and adding in hearsay can further complicate matters.

Ensuring a complete picture

While courts prefer first-hand accounts, they may not always be available. The court strives for balance, and both witness testimony and hearsay evidence may contribute to a complete understanding of the events in question. To fully understand the complexities of hearsay as evidence, you may seek advice from legal professionals.